PHOTO: Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss was unranked when he committed to NCAA Division I school Ferris State. Now he’s playing at Ole Miss and earning mid-season All-American notice from The Athletic.
***
Buy me a coffee to support my research to tell untold college football integration untold stories.
Thomas Shanahan | @Thomas-Shanahan-23
Watch our documentary development trailer: Game Changers
***
By TOM SHANAHAN
College football’s bevy of upsets this season spurred stories about unexpected parity, with speculation centered on the transfer portal and NIL money. Maybe it’s trickled down to the All-American teams, too.
After viewing a posting on Kerry Eggers’ Twitter page noting the offensive team, I was surprised there was only one 5-star player, Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith, and two four stars, USC offensive guard Elijah Paige and Oregon Laloulu.
That leaves seven three stars – four of them ranked above the 1,000 top players coming out of high school – and one unranked player, Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss, a transfer from NCAA Division II champion Ferris State. The average ranking for the 11 players is 3.1 stars.
I thought, “Holy Nick Saban! Where are all the 5-star and 4-star players stacked up?”
Position, Name, School, Stars, National ranking, Class
QB Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss, 0 stars, unranked, 2021
RB Desean Bishop, Tennessee, 3 stars, #1322, 2022
RB Nate Sheppard, Duke, 3 stars, #432, 2025
WR Jesse Legree, Oregon State, 3 stars, #1631, 2026
WR Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State, 5 stars, #1, 2023
TE Patrick Overmyer, Houston, 3 stars, #1538, 2023
OT Patrick Lauck, Iowa, 3 stars, #446, 2023
OT Elijah Pope, USC, 4 stars, #162, 2023
OG Greg Johnson, Minnesota, 3 stars, #511, 2023
OG Kade Pieper, Iowa, 3 stars, #1675, 2023
C Iapani Laloulu, Oregon, 4 stars, #353, 2023
— Based on On3.com/Rivals.com rankings.
When Saban coached at Alabama, his roster was two and three-deep with four-stars. Social media was new and top players followed each other to Alabama like lemmings to build a national title contender and path to the NFL draft.
Remember Alabama’s 2017 national title when Saban benched 4-star quarterback Jalen Hurts at halftime for 5-star QB Tua Tagovailoa? Alabama rallied from a 13-0 halftime deficit to win 26-23 in overtime. Back then, prior to NIL money, Saban’s national title and NFL pitches convinced Tagovailoa’s entire from to move from Hawaii to Alabama? Who leaves paradise to live in Alabama?
Of the 11 offensive players, Smith, Paige and Laloulu fit the pattern of top recruits committing to a handful of schools possessing high recruiting profiles. But The Athletic’s midseason offensive team includes players from schools known for developing lower-ranked players: Duke, Houston, Iowa, Minnesota and Oregon State.
Smith was ranked No. 1 in the 2023 class, but after him, the next highest player in his class was Paige at No. 162. Four the 11 – 36 percent — were ranked 1,000 and above.
Saban’s run of six national titles in Tuscaloosa, 2009 to 2020, was a time when no coach had a better talent advantage. In those days, Clemson coach Dabo Sweeney also was collecting 4-stars on his way to two national championships, 2016 and 2018.
One of the saddest statements on the then-state of college football was after the Clemson’s 2018 national title when Sweeney told Saban in post-game handshakes, “See you, next year.” College football seemed to be reduced to two schools attracting the most 4-stars.
But in 2026, Alabama, in its third year under coach Kalen DeBoer, has dropped to 5-2 and No. 13 in the writers’ national poll and No. 11 in the coaches’ poll. Clemson (4-2) is unranked among writers and No. 23 among coaches. Saban’s 2023 class was ranked No. 1 and Sweeney’s 2023 class No. 11.
The only school with two players on the 2026 The Athletic’s midseason All-American team was Iowa with offensive tackle Trevor Lauck and offensive guard Kade Pieper. Iowa’s class was ranked No. 23 in the nation. The Hawkeyes (5-1) are ranked No. 15 by the writers and No. 14 by the coaches.
The Class of 2023’s top-ranked classes (with 2026 records noted) were No. 1 Alabama (5-2), No. 2 Georgia (5-1), No. 3 Texas (4-2), No. 4 Ohio State (5-1), No. 5 LSU (5-2). No. 6 Oklahoma (3-3), No. 7 Oregon (4-2), No. 8 Miami (6-0), No. 9 USC (6-1) and No. 10 Notre Dame (6-1). Among the 10 in 2023, the only unbeaten team in 2026 is No. 1-ranked Miami. Second-ranked BYU, coming off an upset of Notre Dame, ranked No. 68 among 2023 classes.
Is parity in college football this year an aberration or will it continue?
Maybe the lesson to take from this is fans and the media spend too much time obsessing over 4-star rankings and a school’s recruiting classes’ national ranking. The coaches with an eye for prospects who are overachievers still have a path forward.
-30-
I invite you to follow me on Twitter @shanny4055
NOTE: All facts cited in this story were researched by me as part of writing “RAYE OF LIGHT, Jimmy Raye, Duffy Daugherty, the Integration of College Football and the 1965-66 Michigan State Spartans” and “The RIGHT THING TO DO, The True Pioneers of College Football Integration in the 1960s.”
I’ll put my facts on the true pioneers of college football integration versus Bear Bryant fairytales against anybody, anytime, anywhere. Watch here.
Click here for my first-place FWAA story on the 1962 Rose Bowl, Segregation and Alabama.

— Tom Shanahan is an award-winning sportswriter with two books on college football integration, “RAYE OF LIGHT, Jimmy Raye, Duffy Daugherty, the Integration of College Football and the 1965-66 Michigan State Spartans,” and “THE RIGHT THING TO DO, The True Pioneers of College Football Integration in the 1960s.” They are the most accurate accounts of college football integration in the 1950s and 1960s. They also debunk myths about the 1970 USC-Alabama game. The false narrative co-opted the stories of the true pioneers who stood up to Jim Crow and the KKK.
— Two children’s books also explain Michigan State College Football Hall of Fame coach Duffy Daugherty’s impact on integration through the Underground Railroad and the Hawaiian Pipeline: “DUFFY’S COLLEGE FOOTBALL UNDERGROUND RAILROAD” and “HOW DUFFY PUT HAWAII ON AMERICA’S FOOTBALL MAP.”
***
PURCHASE LINKS, non-fiction books
— RAYE OF LIGHT, August Publications or on Amazon.
— THE RIGHT THING TO DO, August Publications or on Amazon.
PURCHASE LINKS, children’s books
— DUFFY’S COLLEGE FOOTBALL UNDERGROUND RAILROAD, Order from Barnes and Noble here and Amazon here.
— HOW DUFFY PUT HAWAII ON AMERICA’S FOOTBALL MAP, coming soon on Barnes and Noble and Amazon.